The Costly Consequences of Trusting Your Gut in Hiring

Kevin Weir

April 15, 2025

The Costly Consequences of Trusting Your Gut in Hiring


Have you ever hired an employee who appeared to be the perfect fit during the interview process, only to turn out to be a disappointment? If so, you're not alone. As a fellow business owner, I have made the same mistake, and I understand the frustration and financial burden it can cause.

That's why I want to share with you a video titled "The Costly Consequences of Trusting Your Gut in Hiring." In this video, we explore the reasons why relying on your gut instinct can often lead you astray when it comes to hiring the right talent. I guarantee that the insights shared in this video will be eye-opening and invaluable for any business owner striving to improve their hiring process.

Let me illustrate the consequences of trusting your gut with a real-life story. I once coached the owner of a dental insurance brokerage who hired a salesperson solely based on their extensive experience in dental insurance marketing. Despite a mere 39% job fit revealed by a profile test, the owner decided to trust their gut and make the hire. Sadly, this turned out to be a costly mistake, resulting in lost sales and termination after just 90 days.

To help you avoid such gut hires and the financial implications they can have, I've outlined three key strategies that you can implement:

1. Conduct Group Interviews: By involving multiple stakeholders in the hiring process, you gain valuable feedback that challenges your initial impression.

2. Focus on Behaviors, Not Just Job History: Delve deeper into a candidate's behaviors, asking for specific examples of success in core job components.

3. Utilize Psychometric Profiling: Use psychometric profiling tools to gain objective insights into a candidate's suitability for the role and to validate or challenge your initial impressions.

The cost of a bad hire is significant. According to the Society for Human Resource Management, it can take six to nine months of an employee's salary to replace them. This means that a single bad hire can cost you tens of thousands of dollars, not to mention lost sales and wasted resources.

Additionally, if you need further assistance in refining your hiring process, I invite you to schedule a complimentary hiring strategy session with me. Together, we can develop a better approach to finding the right employees and reducing turnover by over 50%. Book the call today and let's transform your hiring process for the better.

<All Posts